Post by bostonredsoxgm on Jan 4, 2010 11:56:05 GMT -5
Signings have gone a little differently this time, and I'm pretty sure the AI has made one mistake.
Here's everything from the new file, apparent mistake on top:
Tigers still sign Danny Murphy (Type B) from Cincinnati. The computer still gave Cincinnati the compensation pick, but neglected to award the Tigers' 2nd round pick to the Reds, at least as far as I can tell. I recommend the commissioner fix this, especially since the computer recognizes Murphy's value as worthy of compensation, and since the computer gave the 2nd round pick to the Reds in the initial file. This signing was finalized on Nov 25 1907 - before the backup date. No idea why the circumstances would change.
Jack Katoll (questionable Type A) still to Chicago NL from Cleveland - still no compensation
Frank Chance (Type A) still to Brooklyn from Boston NL - same result as previous file
Heinie Wagner (Type A) still to Browns from Phillies - same result
Tim Jordan (Type A) still to Boston NL from Washington - same result, including the switch up, so that Washington gets the Doves' first round pick through the Superbas.
Mike Grady (Type A) to Cardinals from Brooklyn NL - important to note that this signing was finalized on Dec 17 1907, so Brooklyn gets the Cardinals 2nd round pick, and a supplemental pick.
Chappie McFarland (Type A) to Cardinals from Cincinnati - this signing finalized Dec 27. So the Cardinals had no more picks eligible to give up. Cincinnati gets a supplemental pick only.
Johnny Evers (Type A) to Cleveland from Washington - Washington gets Cleveland's 2nd round pick, and a supplemental pick.
That's it thus far, that I can see.
Here's everything from the new file, apparent mistake on top:
Tigers still sign Danny Murphy (Type B) from Cincinnati. The computer still gave Cincinnati the compensation pick, but neglected to award the Tigers' 2nd round pick to the Reds, at least as far as I can tell. I recommend the commissioner fix this, especially since the computer recognizes Murphy's value as worthy of compensation, and since the computer gave the 2nd round pick to the Reds in the initial file. This signing was finalized on Nov 25 1907 - before the backup date. No idea why the circumstances would change.
Jack Katoll (questionable Type A) still to Chicago NL from Cleveland - still no compensation
Frank Chance (Type A) still to Brooklyn from Boston NL - same result as previous file
Heinie Wagner (Type A) still to Browns from Phillies - same result
Tim Jordan (Type A) still to Boston NL from Washington - same result, including the switch up, so that Washington gets the Doves' first round pick through the Superbas.
Mike Grady (Type A) to Cardinals from Brooklyn NL - important to note that this signing was finalized on Dec 17 1907, so Brooklyn gets the Cardinals 2nd round pick, and a supplemental pick.
Chappie McFarland (Type A) to Cardinals from Cincinnati - this signing finalized Dec 27. So the Cardinals had no more picks eligible to give up. Cincinnati gets a supplemental pick only.
Johnny Evers (Type A) to Cleveland from Washington - Washington gets Cleveland's 2nd round pick, and a supplemental pick.
That's it thus far, that I can see.